Tuesday

What Parenting Books Can Teach Us About Critiquing


 When we critique, we are often faced with a dilemma. We need to provide the person with honest feedback, but it has to be done in such a way that the author does not feel threatened as a person and is able to stay in a mind space that can accept the critique. In other words we need to provide honesty with manners.

This can be a real dilemma for parents as well. You want to teach your children to be honest and sincere, yet at the same time, you don’t want them to hurt other people with unkindness. Children have to learn the delicate balancing act between polite behavior and insincerity.

As critiquers, we walk that tightrope as well. Although it’s certainly nicer to tell the person with the struggling manuscript that everything is fine, it’s not doing the author any good. You need to deliver the bad news (the plot is struggling, the characters are stereotypes, the voice is off putting) no matter how painful. The key is to do this in such a way that you don’t inadvertently hurt the author in the process.

Here are a few things to try:
  •  Find some good stuff – there’s always some there. You may have to dig, but no manuscript is irredeemable.
  • Avoid extreme language – words like hate, detest, unbearable
  • Use qualifiers
  • Remember that you are only offering the author suggestions. Word your ideas as suggestions instead of commands.
    Ex. “Perhaps you might want to consider” instead of “You need to”
There's no reason to sugar coat a manuscript's problems, but there's also no need to be rude. Keeping these tips in mind, there's no reason why someone can't be a thoughtful critiquer.

And to get my critique checklist so you never forget what to look for when reading a manuscript, like my Facebook page and download a free copy. You can also get a free copy of the Manuscript Submissions Workbook at the same time.

16 comments:

SurfBux GlobalMarket said...

Reading parenting books can help you a lot on how to deal with your kids and on how do communicate with them. It gives you the strategy on how to deal with their everyday tantrums.

Jhon Lockar said...

Hiya, I was reading one more factor about this on an additional blog. Interesting. Your perspective on it is diametrically contradicted from what I read earlier. Im still pondering of the opposite elements of view, but Im leaning to a great extent toward yours. And irrespective, that may be whats so perfect about contemporary democracy as well as the industry of ideas online.

Cardsharing Server

bapak yogi said...

thanks for the info very nice gan
obat herbal jantung koroner

Seo sunda said...

Lumbago is muscle pain that stabbed or pains, stiffening/limitation of range of motion, or an inability to stand straight. Sometimes the pain is felt in the waist can be spread to other areas of the body. obat sakit pinggang

penyakit jantung ace max's said...



thanks for the info
Penyakit Jantung

nayo SE said...

gan the info very nice and very helpful :)
manfaat ace max's untuk kanker

rima rachman said...

a very good job and your article very helpful
Obat Radang Sendi

widia jaman said...

obat yang bisa membantu anda dalam menyembuhkan bebagai penyakit
obat usus bocor yang aman

widi farida said...

info pengobatan

widia faridah said...

hopefully pobud in reinforced on any issue

obat penyembuhan amandel
Tips atasi hepatitis c
Obat Usus Bocor anak
Obat bronkhitis anak

Raihana Faiza said...

a fortune to visit this website
Thank you :-D
Obat Penglihatan Berkurang

Raisha said...

Hopefully useful information that I share
Obat Sakit Usus Buntu Herbal

RatnaSuci said...

Penyebab Obesitas dan cara mengatasinya

Obat Penambah IQ Anak

Obat Penyakit ISPA Anak dan Dewasa
| Obat penyakit maag yang sudah terlalu parah
| Obat Alami Mani Encer
| Obat Kuat Ereksi Dan Tahan Lama DiRanjang
| Menambah vitalitas pria dengan konsumsi telur bebek
| Obat herbal alami flek paru

Martha B. Westcott said...

Admin, if not okay please remove!

Our facebook group “selfless” is spending this month spreading awareness on prostate cancer & research with a custom t-shirt design. Purchase proceeds will go to cancer.org, as listed on the shirt and shirt design.

Thanks

www.teespring.com/prostate-cancer-research

Luki Lukman said...

Bismillah
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
OBAT BATUK
Thanks For Share

Heni Herbal said...

thanks so much for the information that you provide on this holiday.
Inilah Gejala Penyakit Gagal Ginjal Pada Anak
Penyakit Gagal Ginjal Dan Pengobatannya
Penyebab Leukosit Tinggi
Obat Tradisional Triflex Capsule Green World
Menu Makanan Sehat Untuk Penderita Leukimia